Author Guidelines

Journal of Civil and Environmental Engineering (JSIL) is a journal is online and can be accessed openly in, This journal only publishes articles in the form of research (research paper) and the literature review (review papers). Articles in the form of comments (comments of paper) on the articles published in this journal or other journals can be considered for acceptance.
a. Articles in the form of research are research that is original and not published in other journals. The results of research in the form of theoretical exposition with the development of data and in-depth evaluation. JSIL not accept articles in the form of case studies and report the results of community service by the reviews too common. The total length of the manuscript, including references, should not exceed 10000 words.
b. Articles in the form of literature are the result of a critical review of the phenomenon and the planning process in the field of Civil Engineering and Environmental Engineering. The article is not a general review and should be focused on a specific description of one study. The total length of the manuscript is more flexible depending on the description of the article.
c. Articles in the form of comments should display originality in expressing criticism of the article with a maximum period of one year from the date of issuance, as well as displaying a strong argument and is not presented confrontational. Articles will be sent to the author of the journal all for the response to be published after approval from the editors of the journal. Comments and replies to each author should not exceed 1,200 words.

The general aim of the journal is to provide information relevant knowledge of planning, designing and construction in the field of civil engineering infrastructure are supported by environmental and geomatics applied aspects. This information is expected to accommodate the needs of globalization, sustainability, and the development of the latest technologies by taking into account the environmental, health, and public. The specifications of the topics include: structure, irrigation, drainage, water quality, water construction, hydrology, water management, groundwater conservation, soil mechanics, foundation, soil improvement, slope stability, liquefaction, and soil modeling, road engineering, transportation management, construction management, environmental atmosphere and climate change environment (control of greenhouse gases, air quality models, climate change locally and globally), renewable energy and waste management (recovery of energy from waste, incineration, landfills, and green energy, biotechnology environment (nano-bio sensors, bioenergy, environmental eco-engineering), technology, physical, biological, and chemical (membrane technology, the process of advanced oxidation technology Physico-chemical, biological treatment of water), engineering environmental control (desalination, ICA (instruments, control , and automation), and water reuse technologies) and Applied geomatics

Writing and publication ethics

Policy on research and publication ethics should at least meet the following criteria:

  1. Statement of conflict of interest, If there is a conflict of interest, authors should disclose the information in the article.
  2. Author, Authorship credit should be based on 1) the largest contribution to the conception and design, acquisition of data, or analysis and interpretation of data; 2) drafting the article or critical revision contents for important intellectual content, and 3) final approval of the version to be published. The authors must fulfill these three requirements. No changes are allowed after the acceptance of the article authors.
  3. Originality and duplicate publication, All original articles should be written and should not be considered by other scientific journals.

Peer-review process

Articles will first be reviewed by the editorial board's general feasibility of language and content writing. Then, the article will be reviewed by two reviewers in accordance with the area of expertise. Editorial Board may ask the author to revise the article in accordance with the opinion of reviewers. After the revised article, the author must upload the revised article with additional articles to reply and respond to any reviewer's comments. Revision of the author must be completed within 15 days after the request. If the article is not received by the due date, the editorial board use as a pillow publications and articles are not allowed to reprocess the same title. To extend the period of the revision up to more than 30 days, the authors should contact the editorial board beforehand. The review process should be completed after the approval article reviewers and editor. Editorial Board will make a final decision on approval for the publication of the article and may request the correction, revision, and further removal of the article text if required. Final revision must be submitted within one week after the request.

Publishing Fees

As for the article processing fees policy, every article submitted to the editorial office of the Journal Teknik Sipil dan Lingkungan (JSIL) from 2016 - 2023 is free of charge (free - no page charge) including free article processing fees, all the publication costs are handled by the publisher.
Starting from Volume 9 No 1 of 2024, the author will be charged an article processing fee of IDR 500.000/ published article.

Articles submission

Authors of articles are required to register as a member JSIL in advance through the following website address:, On the site, the author must fill out the entire profile data. After all entries in the form are completed, authors are given the option on the "register as" as readers, authors, and reviewers. Then, I click the "register" to get confirmation from the editor via email at the time of registration of members elected. For authors who have registered as members of JSIL, articles sent by clicking the "new submission" in the "home user", and followed by the following five steps:

  • Start
  • Upload Submission
  • Enter Metadata
  • Upload Supplementary Files
  • Confirmation

Format articles

  1. Any articles on research results compiled and written sequentially according to the format: title, author's full name, affiliation and complete address of the author, Abstract, Introduction, Research Methodology, Results and Discussion, Conclusion, Acknowledgments (if necessary), and Bibliography.
  2. Articles in the form of literature composed and written sequentially according to the format: title, full name author, Affiliation and complete address of the author, Abstract, Introduction, Some headings supporters based on a literature review, Conclusion, Acknowledgments (if necessary), and Bibliography.
  3. Articles in the form of comments on the manuscript published were composed and written sequentially according to the format: title, full name author, Affiliation and complete address of the author, Abstract, Introduction, and some headings supporter review comments, Conclusion, Acknowledgments (if necessary), and Bibliography.


  1. General instructions
  • Articles should include an introduction to the editor of the journal sheet (cover letter) to describe a general overview article, specifications of the study topic, aspects of reform (novelty) study by comparison with previous studies. The delivery sheet does not exceed 2 pieces.
  • JSIL may be written in Indonesian or English with a sentence structure according to the rules of raw writing scientific papers.
  • Article typed using the minimum Microsoft Office 2010 with A4 paper size, typeface Times New Roman (TNR) 11, double-space (double spacing), and single column.
  • - The article should include line numbering the entire page.
  • The article should include page numbering.
  • Figures and tables are created on a separate page. Only the headline figures and tables attached to the article as an advice position of figure or table. The Figure format is as follows: images using TIFF format with a minimum of 500 dpi, the image cultivated using black and white format, type of writing TNR 10. The table format is as follows: Table does not use vertical lines, horizontal lines allowed for the titles table and end table-border, the kind of writing TNR 10, and single-spaced.
  1. Title
  • Title of the article using Indonesian and English.
  • Headlines are concise and informative.
  • The title can contain keywords to simplify the search process electronically.
  • Avoid shortening the term.

3 Author`s details

  • The name is written is complete without the inclusion of a degree.
  • Number writer appended at the end of each name authors with the superscript format. Number writer unchanged at the same affiliation.
  • Authors of correspondence should be indicated by an asterisk * at the end of a number of authors with the superscript format. This writer will handle correspondence at all stages of the filing, publication, and post-publication. Coverage of this responsibility also to respond to questions on the future of the content of the article.
  1. Affiliate
  • Affiliate author begins with the inclusion of the author superscript numbers, details institution name, complete address of the institution include postal codes, cities, and provinces.
  • Correspondence author affiliations starting with *, phone/fax number, and electronic mail address (email) institution. 
  1. Abstract
  • Abstract written in Indonesian only if the articles are made using the English language. In addition, the article must be written in English if the article is made using Indonesian.
  • Concise and factual abstract prepared by the number of 200-250 words.
  • Abstracts should state briefly the purpose of research, the main results, and key messages. 
  • Writing abstract presented separately from the article, so it must be able to stand on its own. Rewrote the sentence of the article content is not allowed.
  • The references should be avoided. However, if considered important, reference should be quoted in full, without any reference to a paper in the bibliography. Shortening the term should be avoided. However, if considered important, shortening the term must be defined at first mention in the abstract.
  • The number of keywords 4-6 words.
  1. Preliminary
  • Introduction contains the background, problems, goals, and a clear hypothesis.
  • Introduction stipulated in paragraphs 3-5
  • The study of literature that too much and not too support the issue and research purposes should be avoided to be included.
  • The purpose of this research should be stated explicitly in the final paragraph with a brief description of the problem-solving approach.
  1. Methodology
  • Methodology illustrates the type of research with the kind of exploratory research, descriptive, correlational, causal, comparative, experimental, action research (action research), modeling, analysis of a theory, or a combination of various types of research.
  • Methodology better equipped with schematic or flowchart (flowchart) of the research procedure.
  • Flowchart must be spelled out by loading the details of data collection techniques, sampling procedures, and laboratory analysis, standard analysis, advanced methods of data analysis.
  • The methodology has been published must be summarized and included the reference source. Any modification of the existing methods should be explained in detail.
  • Approach qualitative method should be described in detail on the process of collecting and analyzing information to the interpretation of research results.
  1. Results and Discussion
  • The research results should clear with the presentation of the title illustrations and tables. Tables and drawings were made separately by the inclusion of the title in the article as guide advice.
  • The value of the results in tables and figures should always interact with the content in the article. Some paragraphs of a number of relevant literature can be included as a supporter of the research results.
  • Not allowed to write a series of paragraphs that there is no correlation with the results. 
  • In articles in the form of literature in the form of conceptual thinking on the review of several studies, these parts can be replaced by several headings based on a review of studies and study the phenomenon of research results.
  • Results and discussion is not made separately, but a unified whole in providing answers to the research objectives.
  1. Conclusion
  • Conclusions obliged to be written in this journal and must answer the purpose of research or study purposes.
  • Sentences at the conclusion not an extension of the discussion or summary of the results. However, the sentence gives short messages results of exploration research has been presented in the chapter of results and discussion.
  • The author suggested make inferences in the form of points, not in paragraph form.
  • Conclusions are not allowed to contain references to the literature.
  • Authors are advised to make a list of important implications of their work in the form of a bulleted list. Conclusions should not contain references to the literature cited.
  • Limitations of the study can be added as suggestions for further research.
  1. Acknowledgments 
  • Acknowledgments addressed only to the parties directly technically assist in the retrieval process and data analysis, the research funders, the contributor of materials and research facilities, the provider's very fundamental idea or content of the article.
  • If scientific papers originating from sponsor research grants, authors are required to write the contract number and title of the study, as well as the execution of the contract.
  1. Writing citations and bibliography
    Writing citations in the text and contents and bibliography refers to the writing of the kind of "vancouver". Quote quote written using numbers before the dot at the end of the sentence. Number citations begin and end brackets. Writing should quote numbers sequentially from the beginning of the emergence in the text. If quotes consist of two reference sources, the number of citations written sequentially from the beginning number and followed by a comma; For example: (1,2) or (1,5). If the quote is composed of more than two sources of reference, citation numbers written sequentially from the starting number, followed by dashes, and ends the final number of citations; For example: (1-4) or (1 to 4.8).
    Highly recommended bibliography refers only to journals scientific papers and books. The most important note on page writing is:
  • When the "value of tens" page has not changed, the writing page only lists the dashes and just followed the unit value of the page. For example, a script written journal citation from page 330 to 339, then the procedure of writing is 330-9.
  • When the "value of tens" changed pages, writing pages must include the hyphen and followed the change "tens value" page. For example, a script written journal citation from page 337 to 341, then the procedure of writing is 337-41.

The format of writing "vancouver" is as follows (1-3):

No. type citations Syntax 1. Journals Author (last name) AA (first and second name), Author BB, Author CC, DD author. Title of article. Name of the journal *. Year of publication; volume number (issue number): page numbers.
* International journals are strongly advised only briefly to write the name in accordance with the official standards of the journal. Petitti DB, Crooks VC, Buckwalter JG, Chiu V. Blood pressure levels before dementia. Arch Neurol. 2005; 62 (1): 112-6. 2. electronic Journals Author (last name) AA (first and second name), Author BB, Author CC, DD author. Title of article. Name of the journal * [Internet]. Year of publication; volume number (issue number): page numbers. Number DOI:

* International journals are strongly advised only briefly to write the name in accordance with the official standards of the journal. Kanneganti P, Harris JD, Brophy RH, Carey JL, Lattermann C, Flanigan DC. The effect of smoking on ligament and cartilage in the knee surgery: a systematic review. Am J Sports Med [Internet]. 2012; 40 (12): 2872-8. DOI: 10.1177 / 0363546512458223 3. Book

  • Printed books
  • Electronic books a) Author AA. Book title. Edition. The place of publication: Publisher; Year of publication. Page.
  • Author AA. Title of book [Internet]. The place of publication: Sponsored website / Publisher; Year of publication [year month day decision-citation]. Page. Link (if available) a) Carlson BM. Human embryology and developmental biology. Edition 4. St. Louis: Mosby; 2009. 541.
  • Shreeve DF. Reactive attachment disorder: a case-based approach [Internet]. New York: Springer; 2012 [2012 November 2]. 85. login? Url = http: // 4. Chapters in the book
  • In the book by editor
  • In the electronic book by editor a) Author AA, Author BB. Crosshead. In: Name of editor AA, BB editor name, editors. Book title. Edition. The place of publication: Publisher; Year of publication. Chapter page.
  • Author AA, Author BB. Crosshead. In: Name of editor AA, BB editor name, editors. Title of book [Internet]. The place of publication: Publisher; Year of publication [year month day decision-citation]. Chapter number. Link (if available) a) Blaxter PS, Farnsworth TP. Social health and class inequalities. In: Carter C, Peel JR, editors. Equalities and inequalities in health. Issue 2. London: Academic Press; 1976. 165-78
  • Halpen-Felsher BL, Morrell HE. Preventing and reducing tobacco use. In: Berlan ED, Bravender T, editors. Adolescent medicine today: a guide to caring for the adolescent patient [Internet]. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing Co .; 2012 [cited 2012 November 3]. Chapter 18. 

The authors are recommended to use the facilities to facilitate the revision of numbering Mendeley. The facility can be downloaded for free at
The format used should be slightly revised facilities manually to use Indonesian as a whole, such as the use of the word chapter to chapter and removal p. (Page).

Pictures and Tables
1. Picture

  • Images can be illustrated as graphics and visualization objects.
  • Graphics are not equipped with the right boundary line, the line of the upper limit, and the outer boundary. A horizontal and vertical axis is only intended as x and y.
  • Horizontal lines and vertical (gridlines) in the graph are not allowed to be displayed.
  • The scale on the x and y axes are equipped with many (tick) made out axis.
  • The combination of uppercase and lowercase letters are used to write the labels on the x-axis and y. 
  • Large letters on the label and should be proportionate to the chart legend.
  • Both notations and labels should be written using writing Times New Roman, 11.
  • The symbol on the chart are made darkness or empty instead of x, +, *.
  • Better graphics made no use of a variety of colors, other than black and white.
  • For a bar graph, a gradient shading or symbol used to represent the variation of the variable of the largest to the smallest. Smooth shading avoided because it is not obvious when photocopied.
  • In the bar graph or histogram, white beam pattern or arsian highly recommended when compared with the use of a full black beams.
  • The title picture is only allowed to be written below the graph or object and begins with the writing of the image number. The title image is placed in the middle (center) of the image area with the Times New Roman typeface, 10.
  • When the picture is taken from the citation, image source must be listed under the title picture with parentheses and the number of citations.
  1. Table
  • Table created without any vertical line.
  • The horizontal lines are only made to the head of the column and the last line of the table.
  • Type of writing on a table using Times New Roman, 10.
  • Title to each column of data in the form of information and numbers were written in the middle (center) fields of the table, while data is written in the form of writing left-aligned (align left).
  • Title table is only allowed to be written above the table and begins with the writing table numbers. Title table placed in the middle (center) fields of the table with Times New Roman typeface, 10.
  • Footnotes can be added under the table using Times New Roman typeface, 8 and written parallel to the initial limit of the table in the first column. Instructions footnote lowercase raised (superscript) after writing data.
  • If the tables were taken from the citation, the source citation should be included at the end of the table's title with parentheses, and the number of citations.

The Indonesian version of Author Guidelines can be download here