Towards State Hegemony Over Agricultural Certification: From Voluntary Private to Mandatory State Regimes on Palm Oil in Indonesia

Muhammad Alif Kaimuddin Sahide, Sarah Burns, Agung Wibowo, Dodik Ridho Nurrochmat, Lukas Giessen

Abstract

Previous work on certification of palm oil has reported on a trend toward a change, from failed state regulation to voluntary, private governance. However, recent observations suggest a trend, moving from voluntary, private governance to mandatory state governance in palm oil certification in Indonesia, a move in which the state is reclaiming authority. In this light, the aims of our research are (1) to identify the main actors involved in certification politics, (2) to explain this trend in terms of the actors' interests and whatever benefits may result for them. We developed our research questions based on bureaucratic politics and power theory. A mix of document analysis, interviews, and observations are applied for addressing the questions. The results answer our research questions, i.e., that (1) the state claims back its authority over certification from private actors and contributed to the complex meta governance of palm oil certification, the state mandatory scheme that is supported by states' bureaucracies in charge reduces the influence of non-government or private actors. (2) This trend is due to a coalition of specific state bureaucracies and big industry interests, which grant privileges to industry that are denied to small producers. Unexpectedly, all Indonesian bureaucracies associated with this trend support mandatory state certification, which indicates that palm oil has been elevated in importance to become a matter of national, rather than mere bureaucratic interest. Making certification mandatory through coercive regulatory power is the main tool with which state power can challenge voluntary implementation and reclaim authority. Furthermore, the state needs the voluntary system to exist as well in order to strengthen its position. Therefore, the voluntary and the compulsory systems collaborate to attract global initiatives, which is contributing to the high complex of meta governance.

Authors

Muhammad Alif Kaimuddin Sahide
alif.mksr@gmail.com (Primary Contact)
Sarah Burns
Agung Wibowo
Dodik Ridho Nurrochmat
Lukas Giessen
Author Biography

Sarah Burns

Chair of Forest and Nature Conservation Policy, Georg-August-Universität Goettingen,
Buesgenweg 3, Goettingen, Germany, 37077
SahideM. A. K., BurnsS., WibowoA., NurrochmatD. R., & GiessenL. (2015). Towards State Hegemony Over Agricultural Certification: From Voluntary Private to Mandatory State Regimes on Palm Oil in Indonesia. Jurnal Manajemen Hutan Tropika, 21(3), 162-171. Retrieved from https://jurnal.ipb.ac.id/index.php/jmht/article/view/10798

Article Details

Scenarios of Land-Use Change in Protected Forest of Wosi Rendani Manokwari District, West Papua, Indonesia

Mahmud Mahmud, Wahyudi Wahyudi, Heru Joko Budirianto, Bambang Nugroho
Abstract View : 914
Download :742

An Institutional Model of Transboundary Watershed Management Toward Sustainable Development

Werenfridus Taena, Lala Mulyowibowo Kolopaking, Bambang Juanda, Baba Barus, Rizaldi Boer
Abstract View : 866
Download :738

Assessing Conformity of Scientific Voices and Local Needs to Combat Forest Fire in Indonesia

Meti Ekayani, Dodik Ridho Nurrochmat, Bambang Hero Saharjo, James Thomas Erbaugh
Abstract View : 554
Download :770